Mafia Game 3 Thread (Open): Game Over. Town Wins (8,631 views)

[Souper Troopers]

You really are so terrible at this.

[Heebs]

Jun 12, 2017 17:53:23 GMT -6 FectaDEEZ said:

I hate doing this...but I think its pretty clear that I am not Mafia since I essentially put the bullet in SPLs head. Heebs actions look sketchy AF, but i think its almost too obvious or just really stupid since it makes him look like a mafia member.

Is it fair to say everyone who voted for SPL is not mafia ?

Yes to everything.

[[Account Deleted]]

Well played SPL



I guess we found out yawn was the brains of that operation

[Citizen Cane]

Welp. Didn't expect spl to actually be mafia

[[Account Deleted]]

Heebs is a liability.

I would stay on BK but at least he isn't actively doing dumb stuff

[FectaDEEZ]

Jun 12, 2017 18:01:00 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Welp. Didn't expect spl to actually be mafia

Heebs switching his vote was what got me. 

[Citizen Cane]

Jun 12, 2017 18:02:21 GMT -6 FectaDEEZ said:

Jun 12, 2017 18:01:00 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Welp. Didn't expect spl to actually be mafia

Heebs switching his vote was what got me. 

Is there a chance both BK and spl were mafia?

[FectaDEEZ]

Jun 12, 2017 18:05:13 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Jun 12, 2017 18:02:21 GMT -6 FectaDEEZ said:

Heebs switching his vote was what got me. 

Is there a chance both BK and spl were mafia?

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 12, 2017 15:15:27 GMT -6 SPL said:

My mafia teammates are Pete, Taco and Delap btw... get those 3 next.

So either he's telling the truth here or smokescreen for his fellow mafia.

[Souper Troopers]

But there's only 2 more mafia which makes me think smokescreen.

[Citizen Cane]

Jun 12, 2017 18:28:41 GMT -6 Souper Troopers said:

Jun 12, 2017 15:15:27 GMT -6 SPL said:

My mafia teammates are Pete, Taco and Delap btw... get those 3 next.

So either he's telling the truth here or smokescreen for his fellow mafia.

Well taco got killed as a civ...

[BKay Jewelers]

Jun 12, 2017 18:01:44 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Heebs is a liability.

I would stay on BK but at least he isn't actively doing dumb stuff

I don't want to vote heebs because he seems to be trying the same amount as all the other times he was town. We should really stick with the tried and true and try to make the people who haven't announced their feelings one way or another begin to talk. Do we have to learn the same lesson every game, or can we grow at least a little bit?

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 12, 2017 18:50:39 GMT -6 BKay Jewelers said:

Jun 12, 2017 18:01:44 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Heebs is a liability.

I would stay on BK but at least he isn't actively doing dumb stuff

I don't want to vote heebs because he seems to be trying the same amount as all the other times he was town. We should really stick with the tried and true and try to make the people who haven't announced their feelings one way or another begin to talk. Do we have to learn the same lesson every game, or can we grow at least a little bit?

Trying and leading the town in the wrong direction is a dangerous combo

[[Account Deleted]]

Jun 12, 2017 18:50:39 GMT -6 BKay Jewelers said:

Jun 12, 2017 18:01:44 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Heebs is a liability.

I would stay on BK but at least he isn't actively doing dumb stuff

I don't want to vote heebs because he seems to be trying the same amount as all the other times he was town. We should really stick with the tried and true and try to make the people who haven't announced their feelings one way or another begin to talk. Do we have to learn the same lesson every game, or can we grow at least a little bit?

There's no people I see left who are obviously floaters. Everyone participated in the first round or previous games.

[BKay Jewelers]

Jun 12, 2017 19:01:01 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Jun 12, 2017 18:50:39 GMT -6 BKay Jewelers said:

I don't want to vote heebs because he seems to be trying the same amount as all the other times he was town. We should really stick with the tried and true and try to make the people who haven't announced their feelings one way or another begin to talk. Do we have to learn the same lesson every game, or can we grow at least a little bit?

There's no people I see left who are obviously floaters. Everyone participated in the first round or previous games.

Participating in previous games doesn't count at this point we've had 24 hours in this game. I'm at mellow mushroom right now so I don't have a list of people who haven't said shit, but there's definitely a few who haven't done much except vote after they were already piled on.

[eric]

that was interesting

here's the sheet

i don't think herb is mafia, i think he honestly believed spl was ing it up.

i think the mafia going after taco is really weird. pete as a resident of america's hat voted him, otherwise nothing happened. you can see it either way; the mafia trying to throw suspicion on a non mafia, or the mafia trying to give cover to a mafia and hoping to get a specialist civ. my feeling is pete is a strong player so we shouldn't vote him without further evidence.

timpig's vote for billy to tie against spl is the most suspicious thing i see, but his stated explanation makes sense too, so for now i'll vote timpig but i'm willing to be talked out of it

for the record i would looooove bodyguard protection tonight <3

[Delap]

eric always seems to be very sure that the mafia are going to kill him.

do you have gambling debts that we need to help you with?

[20s Navidad]

My main suspects are delap and pete due to being implicated by SPL

I would like to hear from them

[20s Navidad]

Gbg and canes have also been pretty quiet.

[[Account Deleted]]

Especially interested in delap since he was implicated and voted no lynching

[Lazy Pete]

I find spl's suspect list to be suspect. Seriously, incriminating himself and then giving up his teammates, especially giving up the wrong number of teammates, is pretty transparently a ruse

[Lazy Pete]

I think eric was right in suggesting that the mafia killed Taco to show that I was the lone vote on a civilian

[Heebs]

At this point I think I trust 20s and eric as civs. They were what I should have been as an early voter on a confirmed mafia on day 1.

If I were a bodyguard I'd probably protect eric. I think he might be trying to signal that he is a cop without actually saying it.

I think TimPig's vote for BK as the tide turned against SPL was suspect. That vote tied it up (I realize the exact same argument can be made against me, which I think is a good argument except for how dumb I'd have to be to so brazenly save my teammate). I think SPL's meaningless vote for TimPig to try to give him cover as non mafia (i.e., TimPig can argue he is not mafia because known mafia SPL voted for him) adds suspicion.

I also think Delap's no vote, when an SPL vote with the masses, could have sealed SPL's fate.

I'm on TimPig for now.

[Heebs]

My last sentence made no sense. I meant to write "I also think Delap's no vote, when an SPL vote with the masses could have sealed SPL's fate, is suspect."

[[Account Deleted]]

JFC Heebs

[Delap]

I'm not a mafioso, fwiw.

[Delap]

Just didn't see the value in adding my vote to BK or SPL or randomly voting at that point.

I'm prepared to vote this round as we now have some hunches to go with.

[Souper Troopers]

Heebs gameplay


"Hey guys don't look at all this shady looking shit I'm doing, look at this other guy instead"

[Souper Troopers]

Heebs switching his vote to try and save spl is the most suspect thing this game has seen.

[Delap]

that's fair.

heebs