To be clear, if I were mafia I would target you early on.
When I was bodyguard last TMBSL-themed game, I BG'd you night one because I think the smart play is to kill the better players.
I've got ways to prove I am a town, so I'm not worried, but let's not do the "if I die tonight I'm suspicious of X" thing. Of course mafia would target you tonight. That's good game play on their part.
Sorry - that was worded poorly. I am suspicious of you whether I die or not due to your day 1 actions and the push to lynch someone I think is civ.
I meant that I was posting who I am suspicious of in case I die tonight.
Do people really not understand what odin was trying to do? Saying you think it had 0 shot of ever working bc druce and majic would answer the question is one thing, acting like what he did was suspect (skrouse, Heebs) is another. Billy thinks that too but has been verified civ so I am chalking him up to just another bad hunch.
I apparently do not, as the vanilla civ question has been answered by an admin in at least 3 games that I've played now, a seasoned player like Odin should have known that.
I'm going No Exec because I'm uncertain but idk how voting for a guy who made a blatant mistake would be suspicious.
Because there is no way he did what he did today if he is mafia.
Post by gbgalla24 on Sept 25, 2017 14:15:29 GMT -6
I'm going to assume that the converted mafia member is going to be someone who is thought of as a good mafia player. I'm thinking either 20s, pete, or possibly JHB were converted. I also don't blame them for jumping ship as the odds are ever in their favor.
Billy you have to stop with this vendetta against odin. We don’t have much info to work off of and we don’t have many more misses left.
i bet odin came out as the mafia to get the invests to go to him last night cause he is immune to detection, with a no exec day one, everyone investigating the godfather and a convert, the maf win day 3
I'm going to assume that the converted mafia member is going to be someone who is thought of as a good mafia player. I'm thinking either 20s, pete, or possibly JHB were converted. I also don't blame them for jumping ship as the odds are ever in their favor.
I don't disagree with your logic here (although it puts me in the crosshairs) but wouldn't a more obvious candidate be Billy since he has the most credibility as town right now?
Post by BKay Jewelers on Sept 25, 2017 14:18:44 GMT -6
the town didn't even make odin say his name
like...
it just makes it so obvious that the good mafia players in this game are evil cause anyone with a brain would've forced odin to give up his name after that
it just makes it so obvious that the good mafia players in this game are evil cause anyone with a brain would've forced odin to give up his name after that
Have you or anyone every been able to make odin do anything?
it just makes it so obvious that the good mafia players in this game are evil cause anyone with a brain would've forced odin to give up his name after that
I think the logic of Odin's strategy makes sense, because it would allow him to call out a mafia posing as his vanilla civ character. Although if he were mafia he could wait for someone to say a name and do the same thing, so I guess it's not really all that helpful
it just makes it so obvious that the good mafia players in this game are evil cause anyone with a brain would've forced odin to give up his name after that
Have you or anyone every been able to make odin do anything?
you're supposed to vote them up until they say their name
its mafia 101 you dont let something go like that on day one
you were suspicious of him too but seemed like a pile-on vote so I'm leaning you're a neutral