Post by Face-in on Apr 24, 2015 12:40:03 GMT -6
Ratings
20s
(8 7 8 9 8 9 8 9 9 9 8 9 9 9 6)
Avg: 8.33
-Second best GM in the league.
-solid gm. knows his shit
-Ability is clear, but lack of a title is holding him back.
-5 sim years ago he would have been a 9, but no title success lately drops him a notch.
-great GM. good dude in shout
-Great dude. Great GM
-Excels at literally every facet of TMBSL
2Poor
(6 6 6 7 3 7 4 7 5 6 6 6 5 7 2)
Avg: 5.53
-at one point an elite GM, maybe he should try giving a shit about his team and not canes or ian's team.
-Is he even in the league anymore?
-Took a point off due to him disappearing while his team was a dumpster fire.
-good gm. annoying as shit when he goes into troll mode but we have been getting along lately
-would be much higher but that long absence but a dent in it
-Annoying as fuck in shout. His GM work that I have witnessed has been average at best. For being a dick in shout he is actually easy to talk trade with
-Glad he's back, TMBSL is better when 2Poor is active
-early dynasty nets him some points here otherwise lower
Ank
(8 7 6 8 8 8 7 8 4 8 7 5 7 8 6)
Avg: 7
-knows what he's doing but loves to be a pain in everyones ass
-ank's trading prowess is the backbone of his success.
-Very good GM whose been able to build very good teams without bottoming out.
-good GM, good in shout
-Terrible to talk trade with. GM work is average. His recent run in shout and challenging Soup has soured me on Ank.
- his teams are usually all cock an no balls. another GM if he put effort in the right place would be more successful.
-I'm ready to forget what a rough start he had in 4.0
Bankz
(7 7 5 6 4 6 4 4 5 5 8 5 6 1)
Avg: 5.21
-tries hard but constantly fails
-He's a notch above 2poor, but that's not saying much.
-how he handles his aging roster will determine a lot about his 4th GM ranking
-below average GM. takes shit way too personally
-when he's bad he's one of the worst, but battling back from that trend recently.
-Shitty drafter but been impressed with his ability to turn all those busts into a very good team.
Bruns
(9 7 8 9 7 8 7 8 4 7 7 8 9 9 6)
Avg: 7.53
-Overrated GM. Two faced bitch who runs his mouth about me behind my back but wont say shit on the board. Had arguably the best center in the league and without question the best player in Oscar and yet never won a title. Never got a FA offer in on Emeka and got a shit return for Oscar.
-Success is there, but was it the result of Oscar and Emeka or quality GM'ing?
-great regular season GM
-Probably the best GM in the east, he should have at least one title if not for tough luck in game 7s.
-will never be considered elite without the title. missing out on emeka was rv level bad.
-Looks like he inherited Druce's 2.0 luck
-always banging da the pussy but still cant find that clit
Buster
(6 7 8 5 8 9 7 7 7 7 7 8 8 5)
Avg: 7.07
-good gm - mediocre 4.0
-His trade blocks are terrible.
-honestly higher than i want to put him. his levels here have been nowhere close to 3.0
-Buster keeps it real with me forever. Loves to target his rape victims and pounces like a big cat. Good dude in shout and party chat. Above average GM.
-he's assembled a bunch of teams that looked fantastic. I don't know why he hasn't had more luck.
-great GM, 2.0 was much better for him than 4.0
Canes
(2 6 5 4 1 3 2 4 2 4 4 6 5 6)
Avg: 3.85
-if bruns had his luck, bruns would have 3 titles by now
-questionable moves and awful to discuss trades with
-Canes is a really solid dude. One of the better guys to shoot the shit with. Complains way to fucking much for the luck he has. Isn't a very good GM so that drives his grade down. How the fuck do you turn down Champ or Oscasr and get AI... woof
-Has zero self-awareness when it comes to his value in the league. Thought he could be commish
.-try taking blame for your failures instead of pointing at everything else.
-Born on third base, thinks he hit a triple, and complains that people criticize him for not stealing home on a passed ball.
Dil
(9 6 8 10 10 9 7 10 7 7 9 9 10 9 8)
Avg: 8.53
-very quietly is an ELITE GM
-team has been about as good as can get, the other areas of sim life leave a lot to be desired
-Ability, results, and good looks. The total package.
-Elite
-very good to great GM
-Would be a 9 no question if he was around more. Elite GM and really good person.
Dirt
(6 3 6 6 3 5 4 4 7 3 5 5 7 4 5)
Avg: 4.86
-he should be higher but has been bad in 4.0 to say the least
-Has no patience and most of his moves don’t make any sense.
-great in shout. way too impatient as a GM, let your tank play out for once
-After a really rocky start I have come to respect this man. Loves to trade and is easy to deal with. GM grade would be lower if I didn't like him.
-lacks real direction, moves contradict his words constantly.
-I don't know what happened between 2.0 and the start of 4.0
Druce
(7 4 7 7 6 8 3 8 9 8 7 8 4 7 4)
Avg: 6.46
-he's won titles with 2 different cores. that counts for a lot
-good gm but doesn't put in the time anymore
-he's taken a step back since the last set of rankings. He made some trade blunders to blow up a title team and got lucky signing Lance without the highest offer.
-when he's great, he's great, but those years are surrounded by mediocrity
-ehhhh.
-really underrated and constantly overlooked as one of the better GM's
-I feel like the league underrates Druce. Just a awesome dude and a great GM. His hate for Ian almost made me give him a 10
-Very good GM but is a whiney bitch the rare amount of time that he is around.
Duc
(2 6 3 5 5 3 3 2 3 3 5 4 4 2)
Avg: 3.57
-always making playoffs but not scaring anyone
-he's talked a lot lately about displaying a new level of commitment. i'll believe it when i see it.
-just never seems to put it all together
-Just a fucking shit GM. And a snarky fuck in shout.
-results reflect effort.
-Only knows how to build teams whose ceiling is losing in the second round.
Dump
(7 9 6 7 4 6 4 6 4 6 6 7 6 3 3)
Avg: 5.6
-gives as much effort as anyone in the league, struggles with confidence.
-Pretty good but a lot his success is due to Soup.
-a few months of solid GMing does not excuse multiple years of shit tier gming
-Horrible to talk trade with. When he goes full turd is horrible to be around. But when he is good he is really good like when he was on the podcast or when he is in Party Chat. Should thank Soup for his one and only title he will ever win
-i can't believe i have him this high either, but his results speak for themselves
-had some good teams but who really knows how much credit to give him
Eric
(1 2 2 3 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 9)
Avg: 2
-what in the actual fuck are you doing?
-DOES HE KNOW THAT TMBSL IS VERY FUCKING SERIOUS BUSINESS?!
-Ability is there if he took the league seriously.
-Would probably be good at this if he tried. I’d fire him if I were commish.
-great troll/personality, horrible GM
-His gimmick is hit and miss. Mostly miss. If Ank and Heebs had a love child it would be Eric. Terrible GM who might get better but I wouldn't put money on it.
-not a fan of any of it.
-i was happier before i knew he existed
Fason
(8 5 7 8 10 9 8 7 7 8 8 8 8 10)
Avg: 7.92
-on the rise, still not far enough from douchetank to be ranked higher.
-tank king reeping in the benefits now
-Whether he is competing or tanking, Fason is successful at what he's trying to accomplish. The difference maker for this astute GM is his patience.
-one of the best new GM's this league has had
-he revolutionized the way teams think about tanking in sim league
-Great dude. Great tanker and now a champion. Really interested how he handles a rocky off-season.
GBG
(5 1 5 3 6 5 3 3 5 4 4 4 2 5 2)
Avg: 3.8
-Seems like a good dude. Hasn't made any blunders thanks to listening to Soup. Has a chance to be a great addition to the league
-think he's starting to catch on and giving more effort
-It’s nice that he listens and is willing to take advice. Victor could learn something from him.
-too new to give a good ranking
-Inherited a good team with a bad cap situation. The proof will be how well he can tear it down and rebuild.
-new guy quickly learning, has a chance to be effective in this league.
-has made some encouraging moves. could end up being a good one
Heebs
(4 6 6 6 6 1 6 6 6 6 5 7 7 6)
Avg: 5.57
-Hate the contracts he’s given out and disagree with some of his opinions but he’s done a good job with his team and think he adds a lot to the league.
-he will move up when he stops giving out FA deals every year that he immediately regrets
-still does not know how to build a team, awful to try and trade with
-Really cool dude to interact with. Really horrible person to talk trade with. Just relentless and will grind you the fuck down.
-questionable moves, questionable tactics, overall pain in the ass.
-really starting to catch on and has a good concept of the league now
ht
(1 1 6 5 1 5 2 5 5 4 3 6 1 1 3)
Avg: 3.26
-falling fast
-showed some early success to confuse us all and now seems to be back to normal meh gm status
-How the fuck did this guy have so much early success
-he's reverting to his 2.0 ways
-Good dude, easy to deal with, won a title but I dropped his grade a bit because he isn't around much
-good luck on your wedding this weekend.
-I can't distinguish him from rv.
Ian
(6 5 7 7 6 7 5 6 1 7 6 7 6 7 5)
Avg: 5.86
-obviously knows the software in and out but his tank sucked and seems like its been forever since we've seen our early round exit buddy
-Tries hard. That's the best I've got.
-Good but not as good as he thinks and wish he wouldn’t bring up his team in shout all the time.
-for all his knowledge of the software, he just isn't that good of a GM
-for someone who seems to know so much about this software he should put together much better teams
-Hasn't done shit as a GM without having knowledge of the roster file. Just a fucking annoying cunt in shout. Nobody likes you... nobody. If you weren't a sim league historian we would have no use for you at all.
-at some point the results need to match up with the self hype.
-the emperor is naked
Jerry West
(4 2 4 6 3 3 3 4 5 5 4 4 6 2 3)
Avg: 3.86
-How you fuck up Durant and Bosssert I'll never understand.
-seems like a nice dude, lacks the edge/creativity to be successful in this league.-
-Thank you for taking over for Harry and thank you for trading away Bossert and Reeves.
-Can't think of a contender he has built
-Not a great 2nd run in 4.0 as GM. Decent guy. Probably letting Frank and his circle jerk crew affect him on all levels.
-not sure why he came back
-decent gm. Just doesn't put in enough time and effort
kn
(8 8 7 7 3 6 6 5 6 6 5 6 4 7 7)
Avg: 6.06
-always solid never spectacular
-has had fairly good success. Tough to say anything bad about KN
-Good GM but I think he’s been too conservative about trading away his draft picks
-good GM, just hasn't figured out how to build a title winner
-Wish he would shout more and join the podcast more often. Solid GM.
-about as average as it comes.
-Kudos for drafting McCloud. Fucked up wasting Bledsoe's prime ruining his tank.
MJ
(6 6 4 6 3 4 3 5 5 4 5 6 1 6 4)
Avg: 4.53
-Figured an ex-commish would be a better gm but without Magic Johnson, meh.
-Complains too much for somebody who has had so much good fortune. Want to see him do something without the best player in the game and without getting a ton of help from the league.
-should be doing a lot better for a former commish
-Below average GM and a above average person
-title bumps him up a point higher than he probably should be.
-never has a GM's record been more intertwined with one player
Ocho
(4 4 3 6 3 4 5 6 6 3 4 5 5 6 3)
Avg: 4.46
-A string of great draft classes wasted by some poor trades.
-good but not great. Seems to be on the right path thou
-he's aight
-average GM,
-Not the best GM but he is improving and thats more then we can say about Duc' shitty ass. Quality dude to talk EPL with
-not much success, but young team on the rise.
-Average GM, his rebuild has been meh with all those assets he acquired.
Odin
(6 6 4 6 1 5 3 7 4 6 4 6 7 5 4)
Avg: 4.93
-Too sensitive and unstable. His temper tantrums when things don’t go his way have been sad and pathetic.
-Tough to tell but not overly impressed so far
-too unstable as a sim leaguer.
-high growth potential as he gets his GM legs back
-way too bi-polar with his gming
-Big fan in 2.0, not a fan in 4.0. Maybe his run as commish has turned him into a whiney, salty, cry baby bitch or maybe that was his true personality
Pete
(6 7 6 8 6 6 6 7 7 6 5 5 7 8 6)
Avg: 6.4
-got raped by victor in a trade
-Needs to stop building around mid-level talents. Loved the trade for Porzingis.
-Good GM. Maybe a little too laid back to pull the ank-rape trades necessary to win a title.
-good concept of the league. Just not quite elite just yet
-average GM, top 5 in shout
-Awesome on the podcast, awesome to shout with, average GM who just needs to find a stud
-in the top half of GMs but not by much. wire was biggest contribution to the league.
Rv
(1 5 2 4 1 1 3 5 2 2 1 5 2 4 3)
Avg: 2.73
-good dude, mediocre GM
-I thought I already reviewed ht.
-soft ass bish
-Nice guy but an awful GM that adds absolutely nothing to the league. Wish he would return PMs.
-seems like he might be getting better as of late
-I might be one of the few who like Rv. He just isn't active and he is brutal to talk trade with. He hasn't had much success so his grade suffers because of that
-just bad at this. might be time for sim suicide.
RW
(1 5 4 5 4 4 1 4 3 2 3 2 2 1 1)
Avg: 2.8
-Shitty GM, Stupid human, watch him do a 40 minute podcast about the league being toxic and mean to him
-has played Kaminski at SF for most of his career, I shouldn't need to say anything else
-Great podcasts. Keep em coming.
-Decent but just makes one move too many which shortens his window to compete.
-just a notch above bottom tier because at least he has had some sort of short lived success.
-Has his moments....then blows.
Soup
(10 6 9 10 10 10 10 10 9 10 10 10 10 7)
Avg: 9.35
-the GOAT
-he's not as good as he thinks.
-Best GM in the league and he likes to let us know it.
-Should probably get a 10 for winning titles with three different franchises. Its easy to be a great GM when you get an elite talent but Soup has a eye for talent and knows how to keep them happy. If you want a blueprint on how to do this sim league shit just look back at his run.
Soup as Commish
(9 9 9)
-As a commish so far I really love his commishing so far and he is very creative and knows the software to have some fun but he can be harded headed at times which isn't always a bad thing.
-Can’t ask for any more from him so far. Making Odin look bad.
-Just a beast. Its early but he will likely end up the best commish we have ever had 1.0 till forever. You are the fucking man Soup
Trofie
(7 4 7 9 6 8 7 8 8 7 5 9 9 5)
Avg: 7.07
-One of the better dudes in the league, easy to work a deal with.
-A lot of hype for Trofie as a GM. Too many bad/neutral moves and not enough success to be elite.
-He's got dirt's trading disease, but is a little better at it. I wish he'd let his cores play together for more than 2 seasons at a time.
-Good GM that has ADD with his team.
-one of the most consistent GM's in tmbsl
-been rough lately for him but one of the handful of gms I respect
-the most impatient elite GM in the world
Victor
(3 2 2 2 1 1 2 1 4 1 1 2 2 1 5)
Avg: 2
-Moves have been horrible but what’s worse is his refusal to accept or ask for help.
-you should really seek advice.
-Really rocky start to his GM run. Starting to ask and take advice. Hopefully that continues as I think he is good people and can be a good GM with time.
-it's not a bad thing to ask for help
Yawn
(3 6 4 3 1 2 3 6 6 5 3 4 3 2 3)
Avg: 3.6
-that draft trade this year was terrible
-All leagues need yawns yo
-Builds teams whose ceiling is to draft 1.13.
-i don't believe he cares at all
-Solid GM just never can find that elite talent to build around. Easy to deal with if you come correct. Good in shout and the podcast. Shame he is a Pitt guy.
-rants are great, but sim career is severely lacking.
Rankings
Atlantic
Fason-7.92
kn-6.06
Dump-5.6
Heebs-5.57
MJ-4.53
Canes-3.85
Eric-2
Central
Bruns-7.53
Trofie-7.0714
Pete-6.4
Odin-4.93
Jerry West-3.86
ht-3.26
RW-2.8
rv-2.73
Midwest
Dil-8.53
20s-8.33
Ian-5.86
2Poor-5.53
Bankz-5.21
GBG-3.8
Victor-2
Pacific
Buster-7.071
Ank-7
Druce-6.46
Dirt-4.86
Ocho-4.46
Yawn-3.6
Duc-3.57
Overall
Soup-9.35
Dil-8.53
20s-8.33
Fason-7.92
Bruns-7.53
Trofie-7.0714
Buster-7.071
Ank-7
Druce-6.46
Pete-6.4
kn-6.06
Ian-5.86
Dump-5.6
Heebs-5.57
2Poor-5.53
Bankz-5.21
Odin-4.93
Dirt-4.86
MJ-4.53
Ocho-4.46
Jerry West-3.86
Canes-3.85
GBG-3.8
Yawn-3.6
Duc-3.57
ht-3.26
RW-2.8
rv-2.73
Victor-2
Eric-2
Fason-7.92
kn-6.06
Dump-5.6
Heebs-5.57
MJ-4.53
Canes-3.85
Eric-2
Central
Bruns-7.53
Trofie-7.0714
Pete-6.4
Odin-4.93
Jerry West-3.86
ht-3.26
RW-2.8
rv-2.73
Midwest
Dil-8.53
20s-8.33
Ian-5.86
2Poor-5.53
Bankz-5.21
GBG-3.8
Victor-2
Pacific
Buster-7.071
Ank-7
Druce-6.46
Dirt-4.86
Ocho-4.46
Yawn-3.6
Duc-3.57
Overall
Soup-9.35
Dil-8.53
20s-8.33
Fason-7.92
Bruns-7.53
Trofie-7.0714
Buster-7.071
Ank-7
Druce-6.46
Pete-6.4
kn-6.06
Ian-5.86
Dump-5.6
Heebs-5.57
2Poor-5.53
Bankz-5.21
Odin-4.93
Dirt-4.86
MJ-4.53
Ocho-4.46
Jerry West-3.86
Canes-3.85
GBG-3.8
Yawn-3.6
Duc-3.57
ht-3.26
RW-2.8
rv-2.73
Victor-2
Eric-2
