2: Mafia Game Thread - Game Over - Mafia Win (15,525 views)

[gbgalla24]

I'm now very wary of JHB. I feel like we should never leave it to chance this late. Say JHB knows that 3 of the 4 guys up for random vote are civs, that's pretty good odds for the mafia. Additionally, if for instance eric or BK, who were the current leading vote getters, is his mafia teammate, it adds additional people into the random selection to try to protect his teammate. Better yet, if Yawn happened to be his teammate, it would put 4 civs on the chopping block and we don't get any real additional info because it was left up to chance.

[gbgalla24]

I say all of this while being outside the members on the chopping block; so I have no reason to try to change people's mind other than knowing that this isn't a sound strategy.

[ANK1990]

Jun 9, 2017 7:28:16 GMT -6 SPL said:

Also, @ank if we are all in agreement on not moving our votes, can we move up the time?

No.

Only in cases of a majority vote will the deadline be advanced.

[SPL]

Jun 9, 2017 6:54:58 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Jun 9, 2017 6:18:54 GMT -6 BKay Jewelers said:

taco and canes making the case against bk together, voted together hours ago and keep it the same all while saying nothing of value for basically the entire game. this is the post that 20s is gonna quote in the post morterm thread with a

Im on my phone or I'd go back and quote, but I was on top of helping out with the logic of taking out majic to find out all the info necessary about who way lying between delap and majic. Only thing I missed was missing a line on majic saying delap was a civ which isn't even that big of an error because it was still unlikely that majic was telling the truth. 

If you want to believe eric and BK who have provided nothing but misdirection the whole game. Go ahead. 

The one thing that through me for a loop with all of that was that delap on page 19 (or 17) in the thread in a conversation with me, spitballed an idea of having a vanilla civ claim to be the cop to get the bodyguard protection with the assumption that the cop then could last longer and hopefully get an eventual 2-2 trade off. So when Majic stepped up and said he was the cop, I got a little worried that we were going to vote out our cop if Delap did what he said earlier.

I decided to stay with my vote on Majic is because he was really stupid with his voting selection and what he said. He first voted for delap, then where he proclaimed he was a cop, he said that he investigated delap and he was clean and he voted for Taco. After I thought about it for a bit, that process made no sense and why I kept my vote on majic, why would he vote for Delap if he knew he was a civ? Then switch it to Taco?

right now I am convinced because of that Taco is a civ and should be trusted by us.

[gbgalla24]

Jun 9, 2017 7:32:44 GMT -6 gbgalla24 said:

I'm now very wary of JHB. I feel like we should never leave it to chance this late. Say JHB knows that 3 of the 4 guys up for random vote are civs, that's pretty good odds for the mafia. Additionally, if for instance eric or BK, who were the current leading vote getters, is his mafia teammate, it adds additional people into the random selection to try to protect his teammate. Better yet, if Yawn happened to be his teammate, it would put 4 civs on the chopping block and we don't get any real additional info because it was left up to chance.

Or if his teammate if SPL or Me (which it is not) it could also be 4 Civs on the chop block which would be perfect for the mafia this late in the game.

[[Account Deleted]]

Don't worry GBG you're about to get plenty of info.

[[Account Deleted]]

I switch my vote to Billy King

[MistleTacoe]

Jun 9, 2017 7:40:26 GMT -6 SPL said:

Jun 9, 2017 6:54:58 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Im on my phone or I'd go back and quote, but I was on top of helping out with the logic of taking out majic to find out all the info necessary about who way lying between delap and majic. Only thing I missed was missing a line on majic saying delap was a civ which isn't even that big of an error because it was still unlikely that majic was telling the truth. 

If you want to believe eric and BK who have provided nothing but misdirection the whole game. Go ahead. 

The one thing that through me for a loop with all of that was that delap on page 19 (or 17) in the thread in a conversation with me, spitballed an idea of having a vanilla civ claim to be the cop to get the bodyguard protection with the assumption that the cop then could last longer and hopefully get an eventual 2-2 trade off. So when Majic stepped up and said he was the cop, I got a little worried that we were going to vote out our cop if Delap did what he said earlier.

I decided to stay with my vote on Majic is because he was really stupid with his voting selection and what he said. He first voted for delap, then where he proclaimed he was a cop, he said that he investigated delap and he was clean and he voted for Taco. After I thought about it for a bit, that process made no sense and why I kept my vote on majic, why would he vote for Delap if he knew he was a civ? Then switch it to Taco?

right now I am convinced because of that Taco is a civ and should be trusted by us.

like

[[Account Deleted]]

Civs, please trust me and stand pat for now.

[SPL]

Jun 9, 2017 7:41:06 GMT -6 gbgalla24 said:

Jun 9, 2017 7:32:44 GMT -6 gbgalla24 said:

I'm now very wary of JHB. I feel like we should never leave it to chance this late. Say JHB knows that 3 of the 4 guys up for random vote are civs, that's pretty good odds for the mafia. Additionally, if for instance eric or BK, who were the current leading vote getters, is his mafia teammate, it adds additional people into the random selection to try to protect his teammate. Better yet, if Yawn happened to be his teammate, it would put 4 civs on the chopping block and we don't get any real additional info because it was left up to chance.

Or if his teammate if SPL or Me (which it is not) it could also be 4 Civs on the chop block which would be perfect for the mafia this late in the game.

I am one of a few people left in the game that voted our only mafia member out and I was the 3rd vote on him.

[SPL]

Can someone please provide me a reason on why we are not trusting Taco at the moment?

[SPL]

Jun 8, 2017 21:06:08 GMT -6 SPL said:

Now that I have had dinner and a few libations, I will give my list. My list are going to be in comparison to women of the world.


Heebs - he is my Lynda Carter via 75-79, when she was Wonder Woman. I remember my first boner that I had over her, that is how confident I am in heebs.

Eric - he is my Edie Brickell via 85-91. She looked like my first girlfriend and I got touch her boobs. I think he is good

Jhb - he is my Pamela Anderson via 96 barbed wire. She is not the sweet innocent soul from bay watch anymore but a fiend that likes to get pounded on a boat. I think he is ok but would not be surprised if I felt a burning sensation when I pee.

GBG - he is my Lindsey Lohan via 2007 or so. Not the best bet to do the designated driver back to her place but fuck it, she is hot and why not, what are the odds she gets another DUI?

Canes - he is my Jenna Jameson via 2005. Still hot as hell and they are now getting out of the safe sex age of porn and she has been abused as much as an ear in a Mike Tyson vs. Holyfield fight. You think you should be ok but think the risk of losing your penis might be worth it.

Yawn - Is my Hope Solo around 2015/2016. I loved to think what she would look like without clothes on, then off the field stuff happened and pictures were leaked and I wish it could go back to how it was.

Taco - is that girl with a great rack and ass but really ugly face that you want to paperbag, nail and never speak about or see again.

BK - is that 40-45 year old hooker that has track marks and is missing some teeth. What could go wrong here?


Now that you guys have read this, know that I touched myself multiple times and masterbated while typing this.

Taco in my eyes after I thought about Majics movements has moved up to Heather Locklear late 80's early 90's status. I had a poster of her on the back of my bedroom door in a bikini. I am a firm believer in him now.

[SPL]

To be clear, the 2 right now that I am firmly believing are civs with me are Taco and Heebs. I am pretty sure that JHB and Eric are as well, even with him going after Delap, he had statistical information that supported it and it made sense.

[MistleTacoe]

Jun 9, 2017 7:53:36 GMT -6 SPL said:

Can someone please provide me a reason on why we are not trusting Taco at the moment?

I voted for 20s on Day 1 (because he called me out for not being important. I was being spiteful. I was not apart of the discussion or accusations)
I voted for delap on Day 2 (don't have a reason for this....he was being sketchy in my opinion and it turned out he was the cop....makes sense that he was acting weird but it was an incorrect interpretation)
No vote on Day 3 because I was working
Day 4 (voted for majic)


The only logical reason to not trust me is thinking Majic was throwing a vote at another Mafia, because he knew he was dead, to throw the scent off my trail for future rounds.

I am a civ.

[MistleTacoe]

Wait day 4 isn't up yet. My vote is currently for BK and is remaining there

[KwYawnza]

Can I get some clarity here JHB why I'm holding a gun to taco while you get to decide what person to off? I'm down with a move to try and get more info but it feels like I'm being used like a mindless pawn here and that's great and all but I'm not exactly 100 percent sure of civilian status of anyone but myself and heebs

[gbgalla24]

Jun 9, 2017 7:53:36 GMT -6 SPL said:

Can someone please provide me a reason on why we are not trusting Taco at the moment?

Unless Majic was voting for Taco to throw us off his trail and to try to lump me in with the mafia as guilty by association, Taco potentially clean, but we can't accept anyone as 100% civilian except ourselves and Heebs is 99.99999% civilian.

[[Account Deleted]]

Yawn please just trust me on this one

[gbgalla24]

Jun 9, 2017 8:15:26 GMT -6 KwYawnza said:

Can I get some clarity here JHB why I'm holding a gun to taco while you get to decide what person to off? I'm down with a move to try and get more info but it feels like I'm being used like a mindless pawn here and that's great and all but I'm not exactly 100 percent sure of civilian status of anyone but myself and heebs

Unless JHB was making a move similar to Pete last game, where Pete voted for me to see how people would react to his vote, by suggesting we let it go to one of the four people tied to see how people reacted to the suggestion, it only makes me skeptical of him.  Trying to control other people's votes beside his own is sketchy, but JHB currently has BK in the lead in the voting, and BK and eric were the prime suspects by most coming into this round; so I'm willing to see how it plays out.

[[Account Deleted]]

We still have over an hour and a half until votes are final guys

[[Account Deleted]]

BKay Jewelers

[[Account Deleted]]

eric

[MistleTacoe]

My personal opinion is to decide who do we learn the most about if we execute them. Do you learn anything if I am executed? Eric? BK? Canes?

However, I will stick with the 4 way tie plan if we really think that's best.

[[Account Deleted]]

The lack of participation is frustrating as fuck and an advantage for the mafia.

[[Account Deleted]]

Obviously my gambit to try and get people to react to my votes hasn't worked because no one is here.

I will move my vote back to canes for now to restore the tie while we discuss what our best move is

Right now, here's where I stand:

Mafia: Timpig
Mafia: Majic
Mafia:
Mafia:

BG: Soup
Cop: Delap
Civ: Fecta
Civ: Odin
Civ: 20s
Civ: Pete
Civ: Heebs - vouched for by cop
Civ: SPL - voted for Majic Day 3 pre-confession and near majority
Civ: Yawn - voted for Majic Day 3 pre-confession and near majority
Civ: JHB - trust me or don't, I feel my record is transparently pro-town
Civ:
Civ:
Civ:

Undecided: GBG, Canes, BK, Taco, eric

I'm fairly confident the mafia is one of Canes/BK and GBG.

GBG - has questioned a lot of the moves I've made in the towns best interest and tried to spin them as mafia moves as a misdirect

Canes - voted with mafia members early in game, tried to swing vote for delap when majic was exposed then blamed it on misreading a post

BK - was absent early in the game, has voted with known mafia, finally showed up on Day 4 creating confusion and trying to spin Heebs and I as mafia before recanting. I can't tell if it's because he's mafia or behind

Taco - I don't feel I have any strong evidence either way

Eric - I feel like he's overplaying his "pattern of honesty" to establish credibility and I think he lingered on his pursuit of delap too long, but I understand since I was also suspicious of delap

[[Account Deleted]]

Also add that canes tried to spin me and Heebs' suspicion of eric into a certainty he was mafia this round and questioned my Civ-ness when I wasn't ready to join the lynch mob on him

[[Account Deleted]]

Since GBG is not close to on the block I feel we need to focus our votes on Billy and Canes

[Citizen Cane]

Jun 9, 2017 9:25:18 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Canes - voted with mafia members early in game, tried to swing vote for delap when majic was exposed then blamed it on misreading a post

Kill me if you want, but at least have correct info.

Jun 8, 2017 15:49:06 GMT -6 Citizen Cane said:

Killing majic provides a lot of info. At worst, he's the cop which tells us that both Heebs and delap are mafia which leaves us with one mafia left to kill. if majic is Mafia it points the finger directly at Eric as his accomplice. Worst case but least likely scenario is that majic is a civ and then we are all fucked.

misreading majic's post that he cleared delap was the only thing I got wrong. The rest of that logic is pretty much flawless.

[Citizen Cane]

Jun 9, 2017 9:26:53 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Also add that canes tried to spin me and Heebs' suspicion of eric into a certainty he was mafia this round and questioned my Civ-ness when I wasn't ready to join the lynch mob on him

I question you because you wouldn't respond to my questions of why you won't kill eric. I'm sorry, but there is only 1 person I am going to trust 100% and that's heebs. If you are going to avoid questions, the antenna is going to go up.

[[Account Deleted]]

How did it point the finger at eric as his accomplice?