Mafia Game 3 Thread (Open): Game Over. Town Wins (8,628 views)

[Delap]

Here is the picture:

[[Account Deleted]]

Let's figure out a way to cast one vote for all unverified civs and let chance decide

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 13, 2017 15:32:04 GMT -6 Delap said:

Here is the picture:

That's awesome

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 13, 2017 15:32:13 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Let's figure out a way to cast one vote for all unverified civs and let chance decide

. Please tell me you're kidding

[20s Navidad]

Jun 13, 2017 15:28:45 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

I have no idea. We're fucked lol

We still have a decent shot because we should get 3 tries. 

We should really look at it this way: which two do we think are least likely to be mafia? Let's plan to vote the other 3 out. 

If you guys who are confirmed Civs feel the best about delap and TimPig (I think there is a decent/good case for both as Civs), then vote soup, me and GBG. 

i know I am not mafia but I am suspected by some clearly, so throw me in the group of 3 you want to vote out. I've just longest suspected soup. I know I could be wrong, I'm not saying I am for sure it is him, I just think he has the best case against him. When I look at everyone's game, his aligns the most with what I think the 3rd mafia member working with GBG and SPL would have done. It might just be coincidence

I just think there should be a plan set by the confirmed Civs before they get killed what 3 they want voted for should be. If someone isn't following that, they are likely the mafia. 

I like that even better than my idea. 

Citizen Cane [Account Deleted]

come up with a top 3 and order to vote

all Civs follow that order

[[Account Deleted]]

I will not tell you that

[20s Navidad]

Include me, IDGAF, I want all Civs to follow your order as the confirmed Civs

In theory all Civs should be willing to do so

[[Account Deleted]]

Guys I have no clue

[[Account Deleted]]

Someone tell me what to think

[20s Navidad]

But you should instruct on all 3 votes right now as there will only be 1 confirmed civ left next round and 0 left if we make to the last chance round

[20s Navidad]

AND then we open ourselves up to the mafia member influencing the votes

[[Account Deleted]]

I don't have any more info than anyone else with which to vote

[[Account Deleted]]

In fact I have less because I know the role of 2 people while everyone else but Canes knows the role of 3

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 13, 2017 15:37:56 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Someone tell me what to think

Do what you want, I have zero pull right now. But I'm 100% civ and if I get voted out it guaranteed to civs die before tomorrow.

[Souper Troopers]

Two*

[20s Navidad]

Jun 13, 2017 15:39:37 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

I don't have any more info than anyone else with which to vote

That isn't the key though. The key is they know you and canes ARE Civs and thus aren't mafia trying to set their votes

if you guys aren't the ones instructing, we can't set the 3 votes right now bc people will suspect whoever made the suggestion as mafia if they kill a civ 

that will then open them up to persuasion from the mafia member which can lead to straying from the plan

if you and canes set the order, all true Civs can trust it and should follow it

[20s Navidad]

WIth 3/5 we have a straight 60% chance

If you eliminate people based on reasons, you should theoretically be able to increase that.

[20s Navidad]

Jun 13, 2017 15:40:29 GMT -6 Souper Troopers said:

Jun 13, 2017 15:37:56 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Someone tell me what to think

Do what you want, I have zero pull right now. But I'm 100% civ and if I get voted out it guaranteed to civs die before tomorrow.

I'm 100% civ too but everyone is going to say that including mafia so I don't think it should hold any weight for JHB and canes 

[Delap]

are we to the point that we are trusting people who say they are civs?

I am, 20s says he is, soup says he is... what say you timpig? gbg?

[Souper Troopers]

Some words hold more weight than others I imagine.

[Delap]

Soup hasn't lied in either game. I haven't either. 20s hasn't lied, he just acted oddly last game.

[[Account Deleted]]

Everyone good with voting

GBG
Timpig
20s

[Souper Troopers]

Jun 13, 2017 15:51:28 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Everyone good with voting

GBG
Timpig
20s

Yes

[Delap]

as Carole King says in the Gilmore Girls theme song... where you lead, I will follow.

[Delap]

so gbg?

[Souper Troopers]

gbg

[[Account Deleted]]

Don't vote yet guys we have to make sure everyone is on board

[Delap]

is the deadline in 5 minutes or 65 minutes?

[Delap]

no vote

[20s Navidad]

Jun 13, 2017 15:45:51 GMT -6 Delap said:

are we to the point that we are trusting people who say they are civs?

I am, 20s says he is, soup says he is... what say you timpig? gbg?

This is dumb. It doesn't matter what anyone says. 

Dont put any value in anyone claiming they are civ, it means nothing. 

Soup, delap and myself haven't lied bc we were on the civ side. Gbg hasn't lied either bc he was a civ. Big deal. 

Anyone propping themselves up based on the fact they are claiming to be civ is suspicious. They are trying to sneak out of your suspicion based on "trust" or that their "word means more"? Bullshit, they will be saying I am 100% civ if they are civ or mafia. 

We are all smart enough to realize that means nothing. 

Vote based on anything other than "whose word means the most" when they say they are civ.