Mafia Game 6 Thread - Day 5 ends on Monday at 6pm (6,060 views)

[ANK1990]

Current Vote:

Pete 4 - BK, delap, fecta, bankz
Delap 2 - SPL, Pete
TimPig 1 - Odin
Heebs 1 - JHB
Fecta 1 - Heebs

Yet to vote: TimPig

28 minutes

[FectaDEEZ]

Jun 26, 2017 8:27:16 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Jun 26, 2017 8:23:11 GMT -6 FectaDEEZ said:

if I was Mafia I would be playing this round very poorly.

How so?

I haven't been participating at all, which is a way to get voted off, I voted for the same person in consecutive rounds and got him (Heebs) on my back trying to vote me off. 

[Heebs]

Jun 26, 2017 8:26:47 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Jun 26, 2017 8:22:35 GMT -6 Heebs said:

I'd rather kill Fecta as he is more likely mafia to me.

What has Pete done that is suspicious? I spent 30 minutes on Fecta and didn't pay attention to Pete.

I agree. I think it's because he's been absent and also because Bankz predicted you, Pete, and Duc were mafia. I didn't suspect Pete, so I voted for you instead while everyone else seemed content to vote for Pete.

I don't feel all that good about either vote but Bankz was right once so I figure I am willing to at least try his way once more while we still have the mafia outnumber 4 to 1

What was Bankz's logic though?

His explanation was:

"I'm leaning heavy that 20s spooked the mafia because what other reason would they vote him off. I then followed the reaction of those linked to those men. Go back and read the post and look how they swayed votes when the fire got hot on them. Again I could dive deeper but I need to get back to work."

I was the only person 20s voted for, and 20s wound up voting to save me. Why would that spook me? His inclusion of Duc was lucky. With all due respect to Bankz, who I think is a civilian, I don't put any weight into his working theory even though he hit on Duc.

[Lazy Pete]

I'm down to vote where y'all want to. If not, hopefully the votes against me will lead you to a mafia member during the next session

[Heebs]

Lazy Pete switch to fecta IMO in case someone else is willing to switch.

[Bankz]

The lack of conversation is because of this stupid break in the game...

We also have a working theory so people are just going to let that play out before speaking up to much.

I will say this I would rather vote off Heebs at this junction because i'm much more solid on him being the a member of the mafia over Pete.

[Delap]

I'd switch to Fecta if Pete does.

[TimPig]

Fecta

Don't feel like he's playing like his usual self.

[Lazy Pete]

fecta

[Delap]

fecta

[ANK1990]

Night stop posting

[ANK1990]

Final Day 3 Vote:

Fecta 4 - Heebs, TimPig, Pete, Delap
Pete 3 - BK, fecta, bankz
Delap 1 - SPL
TimPig 1 - Odin
Heebs 1 - JHB

[ANK1990]

Day 3:

The town has executed Fecta - Civ.

It is now night 3. Pm me your night moves.

[ANK1990]

Night 3:

The mafia has killed TimPig - Civ

[ANK1990]

It is now Day 4. Day 4's deadline is today at 2pm CT.

[[Account Deleted]]

Why Tim?

[[Account Deleted]]

Eric is your vote sheet updated? Who has he voted for other than Fecta?

[Bankz]

mother fucking Tim... you jackass

[Bankz]

Heebs

[Bankz]

This shouldn't take long... he's 100% mafia lets get this fucker out... majority vote and move on to the final member of the mafia

[Lazy Pete]

Timpig is an interesting kill. On the one hand, Odin was his only vote last round, so he could be suspicious for voting for a civ. However, that seems obvious and if he was mafia he probably wouldn't kill the guy he's voting for as that would be an obvious tell.

UNLESS it's also a ploy to get us off his scent by making himself the too-obvious target for this round of voting. That sounds like an Odin thing to do.

I'm going Odin

[[Account Deleted]]

I'll vote Heebs again to see if we can validate Bankz's working theory.

[[Account Deleted]]

1 Odin - Pete
2 Heebs - Bankz, JHB

5 left to vote - BK, Delap, spl, odin, Heebs

[eric]

sheet updated

fixed the error in day 2, it was delap that voted bankz, not duc

[Heebs]

I don't understand killing TimPig at all. I saw no reason to vote for him and his late switch to a civilian could have been used against him to suggest he is mafia, especially if Pete is. I just don't understand killing TimPig at all.

I'm pretty off put by JHB continuing to put stock in Bankz's working "theory." There is no theory. It was a hunch.

I'll review what we've got so far and vote a little later.

[Heebs]

Jun 26, 2017 9:30:29 GMT -6 Bankz said:

This shouldn't take long... he's 100% mafia lets get this fucker out... majority vote and move on to the final member of the mafia

When I am proved to be a civilian, I hope people don't take your exuberance as evidence that you are mafia. It just doesn't add up. I still think you're a civilian.

[[Account Deleted]]

I didn't put a whole lot of stock in his theory until you saved Pete. There just weren't any others to work from at the time and Bankz had already been right on a hunch once.

The only other one that was presented was your theory of Duc, Fecta, and I think Pete and Fecta was just proven to be a civ.

If we want to switch to Pete I would be willing to go there.

I just think Pete or Heebs gives us the most info at this point. We're getting dangerously close (two days) from this being a 2 to 2 game.

Our moves now either need to be right or narrow in on who might be the remaining mafia members.

[Lazy Pete]

what conclusions could we draw from lynching me and finding out I'm a mafia or finding out that I'm a civ? Who would be cleared if mafia or suspicious if civ?

[Lazy Pete]

I'm fine with dying but if that's the choice the town wants to make, we should start thinking about what my death will tell us

[[Account Deleted]]

If you or Heebs is mafia then I think we vote the other next round.

I think if one of you is proven to be a civ, I think Bankz could be a suspect. I'm interested to see why that doesn't add up for Heebs. If that's the case then it may be time to go back to the drawing board.

That's all I've got right now.