Mafia Game 6 Thread - Day 5 ends on Monday at 6pm (6,061 views)

[Heebs]

At this point I'm thinking the mafia is just sitting back letting us kill ourselves.

I wish more people would participate. This sucks.

[[Account Deleted]]

I have run through everyone else in my head and I'm not sure that they tell us anything more

[[Account Deleted]]

Jun 26, 2017 10:03:08 GMT -6 Heebs said:

At this point I'm thinking the mafia is just sitting back letting us kill ourselves.

I wish more people would participate. This sucks.

Who would this make suspect in your opinion then?

[Lazy Pete]

I mentioned him already but we haven't really heard much from Odin.

Billy King contributed some on Friday/yesterday but is quiet now.

SPL has been quiet.

I missed a big chunk of Friday and last night.

Really, most everyone except for JHB, Heebs, and bankz

[Heebs]

Jun 26, 2017 10:02:49 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

If you or Heebs is mafia then I think we vote the other next round.

I think if one of you is proven to be a civ, I think Bankz could be a suspect. I'm interested to see why that doesn't add up for Heebs. If that's the case then it may be time to go back to the drawing board.

That's all I've got right now.

This round I'm almost certainly going to vote to save myself because I know I am a civilian.

I still don't see any reason we should suspect Pete other than he has been a little quieter and less helpful than normal. Nothing about Bankz's "he was spooked by 20s!" theory checks out.

Bankz is acting fishy, but I still think Duc's vote to put Bankz on the block day 1, followed by Bankz vote to kill Duc day 2 gives him a pass.

[[Account Deleted]]

I'm going to change back to no vote

[Heebs]

Jun 26, 2017 10:04:24 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Jun 26, 2017 10:03:08 GMT -6 Heebs said:

At this point I'm thinking the mafia is just sitting back letting us kill ourselves.

I wish more people would participate. This sucks.

Who would this make suspect in your opinion then?

All of them and none of them at the same time. That's why it sucks. They've just let us bleed each other.

During lunch I'll study the votes/thread and see if I can come up with anything else.

[SPL]

Jun 26, 2017 10:08:50 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

I mentioned him already but we haven't really heard much from Odin.

Billy King contributed some on Friday/yesterday but is quiet now.

SPL has been quiet.

I missed a big chunk of Friday and last night.

Really, most everyone except for JHB, Heebs, and bankz

Busy Monday AM in my office, but if you check the tape. I was the one that pointed out Duc and voted on him. I am going to give some of my thoughts later on things I have noticed. I think I have a good list of prime suspects that are mafia. When I have time in a bit I will get that down.

[BKay Jewelers]

It's gotta be Pete or heebs here. If Pete comes up civ then heebs seems innocent. If heebs comes up civ then Pete would still be suspicious. Figure out two roles with one lynch

pete

[Delap]

My thoughts are as follows:

Scenario 1: we go after Bankz. If he is a civ, then the rest of his list (Pete/Heebs) seems like the mafia. If he is mafia, those guys are in the clear.

Scenario 2: we go after Pete or Heebs, if either is a civ, Bankz is mafia who targeted duc in a ruse to get us off his scent.

I don't have any other somewhat logical action plan at this point, because there are a good number of conflicting bits of information.

[BKay Jewelers]

Jun 26, 2017 9:57:24 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

what conclusions could we draw from lynching me and finding out I'm a mafia or finding out that I'm a civ? Who would be cleared if mafia or suspicious if civ?

Heebs would be cleared as mafia or civ based on what you turn up

Me as well

Since I almost got you lynched and heebs saved you

[[Account Deleted]]

I was thinking along the lines of what delap and Billy were thinking earlier but now the "mafia hanging back and letting us pick each other off" theory seems really good.

After reconsidering, I'm just concerned what happens if we pursue the Bankz/Pete/Heebs strategy and fail.

[Lazy Pete]

If you lynch me and I turn up civ, then next turn is the last chance for the town, right? I would start figuring out who the target would be in that scenario. I really think that Odin is a good target. Search his posts in the thread and you'll find he's said absolutely nothing of substance

[[Account Deleted]]

Who do we think has the best chance of being an innocent?

[[Account Deleted]]

Maybe if we figure that out we could work backwards from there?

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 10:29:16 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

If you lynch me and I turn up civ, then next turn is the last chance for the town, right? I would start figuring out who the target would be in that scenario. I really think that Odin is a good target. Search his posts in the thread and you'll find he's said absolutely nothing of substance

Ive been sick and hate playing as civ. Im not going to ever sit back and reread the thread to make various charts and graphs that probably dont mean shit at the end of the day. Im simply going to vote for who i think is mafia then hope the game ends quickly so i can be mafia next time.

Literally every game since the first people have been killing me off because im too inactive to be a civ. Maybe im inactive because i am a civ and find it incredibly boring.

The game is called mafia, not town, so thats what im here for.

[[Account Deleted]]

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 10:44:55 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Kill me and find out

[Lazy Pete]

and yet you got mad at Eric for his strategy?

[[Account Deleted]]

I'm laughing because it was funny and I can't click that I'm "LOLing" at your post

[SPL]

Jun 26, 2017 10:38:15 GMT -6 [Account Deleted] said:

Who do we think has the best chance of being an innocent?

I would say I have the best chance, I was the one that pointed out Duc's vote and was the first vote on him.

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 10:46:01 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

and yet you got mad at Eric for his strategy?

I dont do anything to halt towns progress. I read the thread and vote for those i think are mafia. Im just not going to spend an hour analyzing someone elses analysis of the uncorrect assumptions of someone else. You guys can do that, i'll read it, then vote accordingly if i think the info is sound.

The point of the town is to find the mafia, and i contribute towards that. The point of the mafia is to stay hidden, eric does not contribute towards that.

[Lazy Pete]

I guess I don't find shot in the dark guesses intermingled between periods of silence to be all that helpful to the town

[[Account Deleted]]

Headed to lunch. He back by 1

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 11:03:06 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

I guess I don't find shot in the dark guesses intermingled between periods of silence to be all that helpful to the town

Just because i dont post paragraphs on my thought process for each vote doesnt mean theyre in the dark guesses.

[Lazy Pete]

You don't have to post paragraphs, but I think it's helpful to let people know why you came to the conclusion you did

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 11:16:13 GMT -6 Lazy Pete said:

You don't have to post paragraphs, but I think it's helpful to let people know why you came to the conclusion you did

I often do but ive never even be able to vote past day 3 so my reasoning is usually something along the lines of "i hate that guy" or "he's annoying". But you know if im just going to piggy back vote because of something other people have posted then whats the point.

This round im voting pete for distracting everyone with trying to make me look guilty because im doing the same shit i always do as town

[SPL]

Lets take a look at the votes on Duc in the order they came in

Me, Bankz, Heebs, Soup, JHB

With the timing on the votes, I feel real good that Me, Bankz and Heebs are civs as soup was the vote that put Duc over the edge. JHB vote can be a vote to gain credability as Duc was on his way out as soup tipped the vote.

so here is who we have left

Heebs - Civ
SPL - Civ
JHB -
Odin -
Pete -
Delap -
Bankz - Civ
BK -

right now I feel that 2 of JHB, Pete, Delap, Odin and BK are mafia. In the previous round I am very suspicious of Delap with how he first piled on a vote early on Pete. You also had Pete throw an early vote on him then they both switched at the end to votes on Fecta (known civ).

The other act that is making me suspicious is JHB and him trying to justify his reasoning for votes in going off Bankz list. JHB has never been a follower in previous games and would always go out and after people. If JHB were mafia, he could be playing us to go off Bankz list that had 1 mafia member and 2 civs. I feel very confident in Heebs being a civ with the timing of his Duc vote. Pete, I am unsure about.

My feeling based off of what I am seeing is that 2 of the mafia are a combination of Delap, Pete and JHB with Delap being the more likely suspect. If he is mafia, then most likely Pete is mafia.

My vote is going to be for Delap

[Lazy Pete]

Jun 26, 2017 11:23:50 GMT -6 Odin said:

I often do but ive never even be able to vote past day 3 so my reasoning is usually something along the lines of "i hate that guy" or "he's annoying".

Jun 22, 2017 21:28:28 GMT -6 Odin said:

pete/b] because i dont know who all is playing

heyyyyyyyy

[Odin]

Jun 26, 2017 11:27:22 GMT -6 SPL said:

Lets take a look at the votes on Duc in the order they came in

Me, Bankz, Heebs, Soup, JHB

With the timing on the votes, I feel real good that Me, Bankz and Heebs are civs as soup was the vote that put Duc over the edge. JHB vote can be a vote to gain credability as Duc was on his way out as soup tipped the vote.

so here is who we have left

Heebs - Civ
SPL - Civ
JHB -
Odin -
Pete -
Delap -
Bankz - Civ
BK -

right now I feel that 2 of JHB, Pete, Delap, Odin and BK are mafia. In the previous round I am very suspicious of Delap with how he first piled on a vote early on Pete. You also had Pete throw an early vote on him then they both switched at the end to votes on Fecta (known civ).

The other act that is making me suspicious is JHB and him trying to justify his reasoning for votes in going off Bankz list. JHB has never been a follower in previous games and would always go out and after people. If JHB were mafia, he could be playing us to go off Bankz list that had 1 mafia member and 2 civs. I feel very confident in Heebs being a civ with the timing of his Duc vote. Pete, I am unsure about.

My feeling based off of what I am seeing is that 2 of the mafia are a combination of Delap, Pete and JHB with Delap being the more likely suspect. If he is mafia, then most likely Pete is mafia.

My vote is going to be for Delap

Youre fucking high if you think vote timing is a good enough reason to vlear the names of heebs, bankz, and yourself. Duc was inactive and a noob, a worthwhile sacrifice to throw people off he scent.